Comments on: I’m an Evangelical Democrat, and I’m coming out… Politically Speaking https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/ Diverse Christian News and Commentary Tue, 29 Oct 2024 16:09:54 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.8.2 By: G. Blakney https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208769 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208769 Your point that neither party can own God but each person can reflect the heart of God is definitely where my faith is rooted. My faith never lines up with a “one size fits all” party. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

]]>
By: Bob Carlberg https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208765 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208765 In reply to Rondall Reynoso.

Rondall,

Thank you for your response. I agree no party is perfect. You seem to assume I lean to the Republican Party, but I never said that. I identify with Christ, not a political party. I merely find the teachings of Christ to be incongruent with the Democratic Party more so than that of the Republican party. Here is just one example. Christ advocated that the Church be the source of benevolence for the poor, widowed and orphaned. Christ said that if a man asks for your shirt, give him your jacket as well. He did not however endorse robbing your neighbor because your neighbor was wealthier or more “privileged”. IMHO many people who vote for Democrats are well intended folks who have great empathy for the poor, but are very misled in the biblical way to help them. Christ did not give the disciples a free fish dinner, he told them how to fish. (Cast your net on the other side) Institutionalizing poverty and placing it under the auspices of governmental agencies is neither Christ like, nor logical if you are compassionate in deed as much as you are in word. Dividing Americans by race, gender, and socioeconomic class seems to be the go-to of today’s Democratic Party. Spending other people’s money and taking out loans on the back of future generations for social programs will never solve the issue of poverty.

If the church would arise and answer its call to be light in the darkness, rather than seeking to blend in with the status quo, then the widows, orphans, and impoverished would not only be well cared for and fed, we could eliminate a vast amount of government and burdensome taxes and channel that towards true charity and love for our fellow man. I was deeply offended by Hillary Clinton’s quip about us being a basket of deplorables, clinging to our guns and Bibles. That did not sound anything like Christ or Christianity to me. I could never support a candidate that expressed such disdain for those they wished to represent, and she is just one glaring example that comes to mind.

]]>
By: Rondall Reynoso https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208764 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208764 In reply to Bob Carlberg.

Bob, thank you for the response. I would say that I lean more democratic because of my faith not because of family history. Though, I do think that family history allowed me not to have certain preconceptions. No party is perfect, and there certainly are things about the Democratic Party that bother me. I would argue that I find in the democratic party ideas that are more consonant with Christ’s teachings than I find in the Republican Party. I wrote about it some here: https://www.faithonview.com/a-christian-democrat-heres-why/

I do hope at some point to dive into these issues more thoroughly. Maybe you can help me by suggesting a few areas that make you lean more Republican? Hopefully, I will be able to address those issues in future essays.

]]>
By: Mary Morgan https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208763 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208763 I appreciate the fact that Rondall is a Christian and a Democrat like me. Thank you for making sense out of the controversy that Democrats can’t be Christians. God doesn’t take sides on American politics.

]]>
By: Bob Carlberg https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208762 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208762 I appreciate the candor and transparency. In the same interest of transparency, I must say that your essay leaves me wondering what it is, besides association and family tradition, that leads an Evangelical to identify with the Democratic Party. Each time I scratch the Democratic Party, I find it less in congruence with the teachings of Christ. Issue after issue they seem to alienate me and drive a wedge between my faith and politics. As a Christian, I find it imperative to follow Christ even if that means forsaking my family, traditions, and friends. At times that may mean leaving a political Party as well. Democrat, or Republican. Perhaps you can share more about what you find in the Democratic Party that endears you to it and how one can be Evangelical and support the current Democratic platform, or, what it is that makes you love Republicans as people, but hate the Republican Party.

]]>
By: Rondall Reynoso https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208619 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208619 In reply to Randall Balmer.

Thanks Randall. I completely agree.

]]>
By: Randall Balmer https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208618 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208618 Thanks, Rondell. As for me, Richard Nixon made me a Democrat back in 1972. Am I a liberal? Of course I’m a liberal! I’m a Christian—and Jesus instructed me to welcome the stranger and care for “the least of these.” Neither party perfectly embodies those principles, of course, but the Democratic Party, especially in recent years, has come a lot closer than the Republican Party.

]]>
By: Rondall Reynoso https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208617 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208617 In reply to Heather.

Thank you for your thoughtful reply. I think it is always encouraging to others to read comments like this and find out they are not alone.

]]>
By: Heather https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208616 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208616 I was raised Republican and Evangelical, and though I remember a short time when Christianity wasn’t all about politics, the two have become more and more intertwined. As an adult, I have slowly asked questions that had been there as a teen, the questions that no one seemed to want to answer with anything but a dismissive, “the issue is ABORTION.” I am no longer a Republican, but I don’t feel comfortable “joining” any party.

Right now, my husband and I are “Democrat” because voting in the Democratic primary (which we could do as unaffiliated voters in our state) automatically signed us up as Democrats. We have to go and officially unaffiliate ourselves again. We received backlash about that online from another Christian who somehow was able to get this information.

We spoke out against Trump and lost many friends. My husband is a pastor. We have watched as his peers in our area have increasingly intertwined the faith with politics in a “Conservative” direction (We completely agree with you that there is a difference between theological and political conservativism/liberalism, though sadly many Evangelicals have linked them together.) Being anything but Republican in the Evangelical world is very isolating.

Sadly, this is resulting in a disillusionment with the Church, especially among young people. My own college-aged kids are not immune. It is hard to find a place to worship that is theologically conservative and NOT broadly Republican among the congregants.

]]>
By: Rondall Reynoso https://www.faithonview.com/im-an-evangelical-democrat/#comments/208604 https://www.faithonview.com/?p=5569#comment-208604 In reply to Dan.

Thanks for the comment. I’m glad you enjoyed the essay. Always nice to hear from other evangelical Democrats!

]]>